Jan 24 2008
A Commentary On A Commentary
I’ve been fairly active in commenting on one of my favorite blogs lately, and since my comments tend to be long and essay-ish, I thought I’d re-publish a recent comment here.
Bookworm wrote the following about our current crop of Democratic Presidential candidates:
…
Listening to these vapid platitudes, it occurred to me that I could do better — or come up with something at least as good as what’s currently emanating from the Dems. You too should feel free to join in:
“Now more than ever!”
“Peace through harmony!”
“Prosperity through wealth!”
And as you think about those slogans, take a minute to read this Spiegel article proposing a Clinton-Obama ticket for ‘08. The author thinks it would be a fantastic ticket, not because of any harmony of ideas or style, but because it would neatly tag all identity politic demographics. It envisions the perfect election cycle for Democrats, where they don’t have to address the issues at all — they can just stand there and be. (What’s really scary is I heard precisely this idea voiced with great approval at my bus stop a couple of months ago. The neighborhood consensus was that this was a ticket they could go for.)
I responded with the following:
I think you’ve hit flush on when you said that with an Hillary-Obama ticket, the Democrats can just be. It doesn’t have anything to do with actually getting anything accomplished. Like the Democratic presidential predecessor, Senator John F. Kerry, being President was more important than doing anything as President.
I think the 2004 election was a major demarcation in American politics. For the first time in our history, nothing of substance was being proposed. Before 2004, a man ran for President because he had the conviction that he could run the nation better than his opponent. He wanted to do things, he had an idea of where he wanted to take the nation. I challenge readers of this blog to come up with one thing Kerry wanted to do as president.
In similar fashion, besides raising taxes and subsuming the American Republic into international oversight, what particular are they proposing? Change? I have not one doubt that an Hillary-Obama ticket would be formidable to the extreme, one might be tempted to say unbeatable; however, the reason why that ticket seems unbeatable is what’s disturbing, even if true.
All this makes one very anxious about our prospects for the future. And rightly so. But with this said, people also said the same thing of FDR. In his day, men accused FDR of being a lightweight as well. They said he was a affluent playboy who spouted all these empty platitudes and that his ideas are as virulent to America as the Nazi’s were to Germany. Indeed, Hitler and FDR rose to power at nearly the same time and the press were drawing parallels between them all the time.
There is no doubt that FDR’s liberalism tended to have fascistic undertones— in the descriptive classic use of the term as Goldberg pointed out— but you couldn’t accuse him of being a lightweight. He was a juggernaut that rolled over his opposition, and to my recollection he was defeated only a few times, the most salient of which was when he tried to stack the Supreme Court. When he tried to do that, the gray eminence of the Democratic Party in the Senate stood up in debate and called him, “Dictator!” And that pretty much nipped that.
I don’t know if Obama’s empty platitudes and shameless vote gathering is another repeat of FDR, and I personally don’t want to find out– just as I don’t want to find out if Hillary really meant what she said when she spoke of putting a 1984-esque TV out on public streets and town squares in her book…
I think we’re in a strange place in time. There is no doubt that we are in a period of change. But the circumstances of an American revival and renaissance would look exactly like a decline of our Republic into Democracy then authoritarian rule.
These shifts in people and government are not neat tidy events. We all know we have traitors in our midsts, Democratic and Republican, and we have stalwart bastions of patriotism in our midsts as well, Democratic and Republican. Who is who and what is what is for God to decide at this point because I don’t think we can know from the outside appearances.
This election, I’m just going to vote my conscience like I usually do and hope that America’s days of glory are still before her.